There was a time in my life that it felt nearly impossible to make a decision. I felt like no matter what choice I made, it would be the wrong one.
I was living in NYC, doing what had previously been my dream job. But I was starting to arrive at work later and later, a clear signal I wasn’t in love with it anymore.
I was also engaged to my college boyfriend who wanted me to move home to Ohio so we could get married.
That too was starting to feel less and less right for me.
I felt this overwhelming sense of indecision:
Do we break up?
Do I move home?
Do I look for a new job?
Do I stay in NYC, the city I dreamed of living in since I was 8 years old?
On top of all that, there was a recession happening, and lots of my friends in the same industry were losing their jobs.
Was I next?
I was overthinking these big questions in my life, and it trickled down into every decision I tried to make simply living my life day-to-day.
Why did I decide to wear pink tights today?
Do I get my dog groomed or just give her a bath?
Should I bring up my idea at work or will they think it’s bonkers?
It was getting harder and harder to function.
The stress was so heavy, my body was breaking down. I ended up in the ER with phantom pain that literally had me doubled over, but the doctors could find nothing wrong.
Why You’re Overthinking Every Decision: Stress, Social Media, and Choice Overload
Overthinking is the word I hear most from early-career pros.
Not just about big things like jobs or relationships.
But what to eat. What to wear. What to text back.
Why? Stress can affect the mental tools we use to make decisions.
A review of research on stress and decision-making describes how stress can interfere with working memory and flexible thinking, the abilities that help us hold different options in mind and weigh them against each other.
It doesn’t affect everyone or every decision the same way, but it can make choosing harder when we’re already overwhelmed.
And whether you admit it or not, our social-media-driven world has got your brain stresssssin’.
Because you’re not choosing between two options anymore.
You’re choosing between entire lifestyles.
Social media can put what feels like a thousand possible lives in front of you:
Corporate. Creative. Freelance. Digital nomad. Move abroad. Stay home. Start a business. Go back to school.
When you’re already unsure what you want, all those possibilities can feel like a lot to sort through.
Researchers call this “choice overload”: when having more options makes choosing harder rather than easier.
A large review of choice-overload research found that more options aren’t always a problem. They’re more likely to become overwhelming when the options are complicated, the decision is difficult, or you’re unsure what you actually want.
In those situations, people can feel less confident, experience more regret, or put off choosing altogether.
Add constant comparison and the pressure to “choose the right path,” and suddenly every decision feels super heavy.
There’s research behind the comparison piece, too. A meta-analysis of 48 experiments found that seeing people who appear better off on social media can make us feel worse about ourselves.
So those other lives aren’t always just interesting possibilities. They can become a measuring stick for our own.
So what can you do when you find yourself overthinking the heck outta everything?
The goal isn’t to find the perfect answer.
It’s to make the decision feel a little less overwhelming and give yourself a way to move forward.
Here are four places to start.
1. Figure out what matters to you right now.
Before you ask, “What should I do?” ask, “What do I need?”
More stability? More creativity? More time? A chance to learn?
Stop worrying about what looks impressive. Don’t consider what your college roommate is doing. What matters to you, in this season of your life?
Choosing gets harder when we’re unsure what we want or how to compare the options. Getting clear on your priorities is one way to put that finding into practice.
📍Write down two or three things that matter most. Let those be your starting point.
2. Make a shortlist.
You don’t need to consider every possible version of your future.
You can be curious about all of them without keeping all of them on the table right now.
📍So choose a few realistic next steps that fit your priorities.
Three is a place to start.
3. Give yourself some space from comparison.
Before you open Instagram to see what everyone else is doing, write down what you want.
Remember, seeing people who appear better off on social media can make us feel worse about ourselves. That doesn’t prove scrolling causes indecision. But it’s a good reason to notice how comparison is affecting you.
If certain accounts consistently leave you feeling behind, try taking a break from them.
Not forever. Just as an experiment.
📍Give yourself a little space to figure out whether you actually want something or whether you’re feeling pressure to want it.
4. Turn your next step into a specific plan.
“I should look for a new job” leaves a lot of room for more thinking.
“Tuesday after dinner, I’ll spend 20 minutes researching one role I’m curious about” gives you something to do.
Researchers call these “if–then” plans, or implementation intentions.
They can help people follow through on their goals by connecting a specific situation with a specific action. They won’t tell you whether a choice is right, but they can help you act on the next step you’ve chosen.
📍Pick one small action. Decide when you’ll take it.
Then notice what you learn.
What interested you? What didn’t feel right? What would you try differently?
You don’t need certainty about your entire future to make progress toward it. In fact, every small step sparks self-belief along the way.
Most of all, trust yourself.
💜 Brianne
🙋♀️ PS: I Will Answer Your Interview Questions Live
When I was 22, I had no one to text when my manager gave me vague feedback or when an offer came in lower than I hoped. I figured it out the slow way, through a lot of trial and error.
You don’t have to.
You can have me in your corner every month. Here’s everything you get:
A live Q&A with me every month. Bring the question you’ve been too nervous to ask anyone at work. How to negotiate your salary, what hiring managers look for, how to make friends in a new city. Nothing is off limits.
The member community, aka your early-career group chat. Share a win or ask for advice on a tricky boss situation.
The full Premium Library. That includes my 20 interview frameworks with an AI grader, the Career Confidence With EQ Playbook, a step-by-step guide to setting up your 401(k), and advice from 12 successful women on what they wish they knew at 22. And I add new resources all the time.
Membership costs $15 a month, or $65 for the year. The annual plan saves you 64%, which works out to about $5 bucks a month.
Want me in your corner one-on-one? Founding Members also get a mock interview with real-time feedback from me, so you walk into the real thing ready.
🥳 PPS: Real Jobs Without 1000s of Applications
The usual job boards are littered with fake job postings and ones that already have thousands of people already applying.
That’s why when I find a good (REAL) opportunity, I am going to start sharing them here. If you’re job searching, this is a great section for you to check out each week.
Today’s job postings:
Manager, Consumer Marketing Strategy
Company: Ford Motor Company
Employment Type: Full time
Date posted: 11/10/2026
Dearborn, Michigan, United States
Why I love this opportunity: they literally say, “You may not check every box, or your experience may look a little different from what we’ve outlined, but if you think you can bring value to Ford Motor Company, we encourage you to apply!”
Programmatic Advertising Account Specialist
Company: Spectrum
Employment Type: Full Time
Date posted: 11/10/2026
New York, New York, United States
What I love this opportunity: pay transparency, benefits packages
Go get it!


